|
Home Produce Articles
Archives
Order Recipes Contact Us Email Us

| |
Mexican imports put Florida Farmers in peril.
Orlando Sentinel, Sunday, February 4, 1996
Wholesale prices have plummeted well below what it costs U.S. farmers to
grow them.
Teena Borek inspects her crop of ripe tomatoes. She doubts her farm
can survive the flood of Mexican produce streaming across the US border.
This surge of cheaper prices has reduced wholesale prices to 8 cents a pound, well below
Borek's cost of 32 cents a pound. She would lose money if she hired workers to pick the
crop.
On Saturday, Borek plans to invite the public to pick her crop for 8 cents a
pound. She hopes the price will shock consumers into thinking about the plight of South
Dade farmers. Borek says she thinks the crisis will cause many farmers to quit.
Teena Borek didn't know a lick about farming when her husband died 16
years ago leaving her with two toddlers and a mountain of debts. She had no choice but to
work hard to save his farm for her family's future.
It wasn't easy. Over the years, the hardy Newfoundland native survived two
killer freezes. She bounced back after Hurricane Andrew wiped out Dade County's $1 billion
agriculture industry, including the lime grove she had just bought.
She didn't give up two years later when a rare November storm deluged freshly
planted crops.
But today, Borek, 41, doubts she can survive the flood of Mexican imports
streaming across the U.S. border every day. This surge of cheaper imports has sent
wholesale prices of tomato, squash, and other vegetable plummeting, often below what it
costs Florida farmers to grow them.
Unable to turn a profit, many South Dade farmers who raise almost half the
winter vegetables grown in the United States are leaving acres and acres of tomatoes to
rot. To her dismay, 40 of those acres are Borek's. Another 40 belong to her nephew, Jason,
a young farmer who was encouraged by, amidst other things, a $160, 000 government loan to
plant tomatoes.
"I have never, ever had to leave a crop in the field," Borek said,
her blue eyes weary, her blue jeans covered with dirt. "Never. What natural disaster
can't do to us, our own government is doing to us. I know international trade is her to
stay. You can't fight it, but your own government shouldn't help another country beat you
down."
These days, South Dade seems like a community on the ropes. With 35,000 acres
and about 260 farms devoted to growing $265 million worth of winter vegetables, despair is
everywhere:
* Bankers, saddled with unpaid loans, predict as many as 35 percent of vegetable farmers
could be out of business by year's end.
* Grading machines in packing houses sit idle.
* Migrant farmers accustomed to working seven days a week are lucky to work one.
* Owners of paint stores, lumber yards and restaurants see their own fortunes declining as
their customers struggle to survive.
"I have businesses that aren't sure they can keep their doors open
another year," said Kim Sovia, president of the Greater Homestead/Florida City
Chamber of Commerce. "Furniture stores, antiques stores, little restaurants. They all
depend upon agriculture, and I foresee agriculture slowly dying. Our government is putting
the industry out of business."
Feelings of betrayal over the 1993
North American Free Trade Agreement run as deeply as the despair.
Peso sinks, exports soar.
Most industry analysts, however, say the dramatic 70 percent de-valuation of the Mexican
peso is the primary reason for the surges in Mexican produce. The lower the peso, the less
expensive Mexican products are, the more Mexico wants to sell to the US- for dollars.
But farmers here lay the blame for the bleak times squarely on President
Clinton, who they say has not fulfilled the promises he made when securing support for
NAFTA. The trade pact phases out tariffs and lowers trade barriers among Canada, Mexico
and the United States.
Initially a hard sell in Florida, NAFTA won support of Florida's
congressional delegation only after members secured a written pledge from Clinton to
protect the U.S. vegetable industry.
In a Nov. 16, 1993 letter to former U.S. Rep. Tom Lewis R- North Palm Beach,
Clinton said NAFTA and U.S. trade laws contained the necessary measures to monitor prices
and control export surges from Mexico. If Mexico exceeded its quota on vegetable
shipments, Clinton assured, NAFTA would impose higher tariffs. If cheaper- to-produce
Mexican imports were imperiling the U.S. vegetable industry, Clinton said, he would
intervene to protect the domestic industry until it could adjust.
Trouble is, spokesman for U.S. Sen. Bob Graham and the agriculture industry say, trade
laws lack the power to protect seasonal industries from foreign imports.
House stalls Graham effort.
On top of that, the procedures to impose higher protective tariffs in a timely manner are
not in place.
In 1995, for example, Mexican imports exceeded their quota long before U.S.
Customs Service imposed the higher tariffs- making the tariffs meaningless.
Reacting to what he considers a do-or-die emergency for Florida's farmers, Graham
met with agriculture and trade representatives and introduced corrective legislation. He
reported some progress Friday. Effective immediately, Graham said the Customs Service will
change its procedures to collect tariffs promptly.
Calling the action a "modest step in the right direction," Graham
said Florida farmers are still in need of urgent relief.
"I have looked people in the eye who face bankruptcy in 30 days,"
he wrote. "I've heard their voices crack with emotion as they talk about laying off
employees and letting crops rot in the field."
Graham faces a tougher challenge on legislation that would make it
easier for seasonal industries- such as vegetable farming- to petition for the president
for relief from increased imports. Backed by the Clinton administration and U.S. Trade
Representative Mickey Kantor, the bill unanimously passed the Senate on Jan. 26. But the
House tabled it last week when leaders decided there was no immediate need to consider it.
When she read that, Borek felt as if she had been kicked in the teeth. Facing
a $30, 000 payment on her tractors and earning cents for a pound of tomatoes that cost her
32 cents to grow, she thinks farmers who perennially threaten to quit will have no choice
but to follow through.
Homestead bankers share her pessimism. Bob Epling, president of Community
Bank in Homestead, predicted that if the tomato market doesn't turn around soon- very
soon- 35 percent of South Dade's vegetable farmers will be forced to liquidate their
assets. With mounting debts, losses and everything they own used as collateral, farmers
are not able to get loans for next season.
Epling should know. He attributes 35 percent, or roughly $45 million worth,
of the outstanding loans at his bank to agriculture.
Each acre of tomatoes, for example, represents a $5,000 investment for the
farmers.
Dade Farmers are not the only ones in distress. Bob Blankenship, a
spokesman for the state Department of Agriculture, said Mexican imports are squeezing
farmers statewide. But with their shorter season and head-to-head competition with Mexico,
Dade Farmers are just being squeezed faster and faster.
"Other parts of the state are not as heads-up against Mexico," Blankenship said
"Part of the season they can make a buck and afford to lose a buck. Dade County does
not have that luxury."
Consumers not benefiting.
Frustrated, Borek is grabbing at straws. For now, she is planning a direct appeal to
consumers who, she says, are not reaping the reward of free trade at the supermarket.
Retail tomato prices haven't plummeted as wholesale prices have.
On Saturday, she hopes to invite people to pick her tomatoes for 8 cents a
pound, the same price her crop gets on the market.
She hopes the ridiculous price will shock consumers into thinking about South
Dade farmers who have been growing much of the beans, squash, eggplant and bell peppers
they eat every winter. With an expected cold front approaching, she also held out hope
they'll remember their history.
"What happened in the freeze of 1989 is a fact: the minute we froze,
Mexican tomatoes went sky high," Borek said "If Mexico pushes U.S. farmers out
of business, there will be a permanent freeze. Nobody will be able to afford
tomatoes."
|